Brooklyn Pizza

Reviews

• Mary K.

  star star star star_border star_border 7 June 2026

  Got the menu in the mail and decided to give it a try. I was so excited there was another delivery option in our area.  We ordered a large pepperoni pizza and a calzone. I'm not sure if it was just a bad day for them or for me but both the pizza and calzone were very bland. The calzone was so greasy it leaked through the box all over my counter. It was stuffed well with the toppings I chose but still so bland and flavorless and it was difficult to get past the grease.  I ended up just throwing it away.  The pizza was meh!! So disappointing.
  
  I did like that they have a large variety of items to choose from so I may try again with something other than pizza.
  
  I give 3 stars for the customer service which was friendly and the order was correct. Delivery was within the 45 minutes as told and the prices were fair.

• Sean E.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 5 June 2026

  Ordered food and were told it would be 30 minutes. After a hour and a half we called up there and kept getting hung up on or put on hold. After finally talking to somebody they said it should be over within 10 minutes. They show up with not all the food. No compensation or anything. Just sorry about not having food for a hour and a half.

• Nicky T.

  star star star star star 24 May 2026

  These guys make an awesome Chicken Florentine Bianca pizza!! We usually get that and a Greek, both are delicious! Their style is more of a thinner dough and crust, so I would say it's not as filling and you'll eat more because its not 60% dough like Papa John's. It's not overly greasy either. They have good subs too. I enjoy the Eggplant Parmigiana and Club personally. Antipasto and Greek salads are also good. This is our local order out, and they've stayed consistent in their quality and service! We no longer order chain pizza because of these guys! Thank you Brooklyn!

• Corey M.

  star star star star star_border 22 May 2026

  Nice place . Great spot for lunch with great lunch specials. The staff is friendly, and alot of local eat here often. The only thing I've had so far was the pizza . But I will say the pizza is great.  Really has a nice flavor and is very feeling and the price is just right

• Daniel S.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 21 May 2026

  Fried mushrooms undercooked , Stromboli cold in the middle.  Place was dead and looks like it's going under. There is a reason there's nobody there.  At least get the food hot a cooked right. By the time I got the Stromboli my friends were done eating. No compensation offered for my time. Based on this I would never order delivery because they can't cook food properly.  In fact you have seen my last dollar. Never again.